Shelter Island

Why you'd want to live in Shelter Island

Shelter Island, which sits between the North and South forks of Long Island, can only be reached by boat or a short car ferry ride at each end, a quirk that’s helped preserve its lush, unhurried feel. The island has just one supermarket and one gas station to serve its 2,400 year-round residents, and the lone drug store still has a no-frills lunch counter tucked to one side. But if you know where to look, more happens on Shelter Island than meets the eye.

Shelter Island Market Report

$2,169,286

AVERAGE PRICE OF 14 HOMES

$2,918,000

AVERAGE PRICE OF 10 MULTI-MILLION DOLLAR HOMES

$4,750,000

AVERAGE PRICE OF 3 NEWLY BUILT HOMES

$2,251,250

AVERAGE PRICE OF 8 HOMES WITH A POOL

Average Home

Average Price $2,169,286
Avg Bedrooms 3.29 beds
Avg Bathrooms 3.21 baths

Average Price by Bedrooms

3 bedrooms $1,867,000
4 bedrooms $1,819,000
5 bedrooms $9,750,000
Shelter Island Home Price Trends
  11/2023 10/2023 9/2023 8/2023 7/2023
Total Listings 14 11 11 14 18
Average Price $2,205,335 $1,538,616 $1,119,535 $1,008,402 $1,018,808
Avg Price Change +43.33% +37.43% +11.02% -1.03% -8.77%
Median Price $1,782,586 $1,387,586 $1,107,759 $1,035,345 $1,016,643
Med Price Change +28.47% +25.26% +6.99% +1.84% -10.31%
Avg Bedrooms 3.28 beds 3.08 beds 2.95 beds 2.81 beds 3.03 beds
Avg Bathrooms 3.1 baths 2.65 baths 2.39 baths 2.33 baths 2.58 baths
Home Price by High School
School Name Total Homes Average Price Avg Days on Site
Shelter Island School 14 $2,169,286 108 days
Home Price by House Size
Total Homes Average Price Avg Days on Site
All Homes 14 $2,169,286 108 days
Multi-Million Dollar Homes 10 $2,918,000 86 days
Newly Built Homes 3 $4,750,000 81 days
Homes with a Pool 8 $2,251,250 128 days
Compass | Ambrose Fingleton Team
63 Main Street
East Hampton, NY 11937
Jessy Fingleton- 631-374-3151
Clare Ambrose- 631-806-8997
ambrosefingletonteam@compass.com

The data relating to real estate for sale or lease on this web site comes in part from One Key, Inc. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Jessy Scherlein-Fingleton - Compass are marked with the One Key, Inc logo or an abbreviated logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker.

The information appearing herein has not been verified by One Key, Inc or by any individual(s) who may be affiliated with said entities, all of whom hereby collectively and severally disclaim any and all responsibility for the accuracy of the information appearing at this web site, at any time or from time to time. All such information should be independently verified by the recipient of such data. This data is not warranted for any purpose.

©2023 One Key, Inc. All rights reserved.

This site powered by CINC: www.cincpro.com